| Year | Course | Champion | Runner-Up | Buxton/Paquet Cup |
| 1930 | Rutland | Mrs. Fred B. Davis | Mrs. J.J. Schroder | |
| 1931 | Equinox | Mrs. J.J. Thonpson | Miss Virginia Pierce | Equinox |
| 1932 | Burlington | Miss Virginia Pierce | Miss Jane Evans | Rutland |
| 1933 | Rutland | Miss Virginia Pierce | Miss Ina Freeland | Rutland |
| 1934 | Woodstock | Mrs. John W. Goss | Mrs. H.B. Jones | Montpelier |
| 1935 | Barre | Miss. Virginia Pierce | Mrs. F.C. Corry | Burlington |
| 1936 | Burlington | Mrs. T.A. Todd | Mrs. Stewart Scott | Montpelier |
| 1937 | Rutland | Miss Marjorie Harrison | Mrs. H.B. Jones | Rutland |
| 1938 | Brattleboro | Miss Marjorie Harrison | Miss Carolyn Cassidy | Brattleboro |
| 1939 | Burlington | Mrs. H.B. Jones | Miss Lydia Barber | Burlington |
| 1940 | Rutland | Mrs. H.B. Jones | Mrs. C.H. Beecher | Rutland |
| 1941 | Brattleboro | Miss Mae Murray | Mrs. E.H.MacFarland | Rutland |
| 1942 | N/A – War Years | |||
| 1943 | N/A – War Years | |||
| 1944 | N/A – War Years | |||
| 1945 | N/A – War Years | |||
| 1946 | Burlington | Miss Mae Murray | Miss Mary Fenton | Rutland |
| 1947 | Rutland | Miss Mae Murray | Mrs. Stan Neptune | Rutland |
| 1948 | Brattleboro | Miss Mae Murray | Mrs. C.D. Inman | Rutland |
| 1949 | Barre | Miss Mae Murray | Miss Gertrude Dobbs | Rutland |
| 1950 | Mt. Anthony | Miss Alma Ace | Mrs. C.D. Inman | Brattleboro |
| 1951 | Burlington | Miss Susan Inman | Miss Doris Seymour | Rutland |
| 1952 | Rutland | Miss Mae Murray | Rutland | |
| 1953 | Equinox | Miss Susan Inman | Ekwanok | |
| 1954 | Burlington | Mrs. James Ogsbury | Rutland | |
| 1955 | Rutland | Mrs. H. Stetson Fletcher | Rutland | |
| 1956 | Woodstock | Miss Monica LaCroix | Rutland | |
| 1957 | Ekwanok | Mrs. Chadwick Ramsdell | Monica LaCroix | Rutland |
| 1958 | Burlington | Mrs. C.H. Beecher | Charlotte Fletcher | Rutland |
| 1959 | Rutland | Mrs. H. Stetson Fletcher | Virginia Smith | Rutland |
| 1960 | Equinox | Mrs. Peter Donovan, Jr. | Mrs. H. Stetson Fletcher | Rutland |
| 1961 | Woodstock | Mrs. H. Stetson Fletcher | Monica LaCroix | Rutland |
| 1962 | Burlington | Monica LaCroix | Burlington | |
| 1963 | Orleans | Patty Harrington | Burlington | |
| 1964 | Crown Point | Monica LaCroix | Patty Harrington | Rutland |
| 1965 | Rutland | Patty Harrington | Gail Arnold | Barre |
| 1966 | Burlington | Patty Harrington | Sylvia Jolivette | Barre |
| 1967 | Orleans | Gail Arnold | Marjorie Kanrich | Rutland |
| 1968 | Woodstock | Gail Arnold | Sylvia Jolivette | Copley |
| 1969 | CPCC/Equinox | Sylvia Jolivette | Mary Drescher | Copley |
| 1970 | Rutland | Sylvia Jolivette | Mary Drescher | Burlington |
| 1971 | Burlington | Cindy Paquet | Mary Drescher | Burlington |
| 1972 | Kwiniaska | Cindy Paquet | Mary Drescher | Burlington |
| 1973 | Orleans | Mary Drescher | Mickie LaCroix | Burlington |
| 1974 | Crown Point | Betsy Weston | Cindy Paquet | Crown Point |
| 1975 | Barre | Cindy Paquet | Mary McNeill | Kwiniaska |
| 1976 | Mt. Anthony | Cindy Paquet | Mary McNeill | Kwini/Burlington |
| 1977 | Manchester | Cindy Paquet | Sue Dresser | Stowe |
| 1978 | Orleans | Mickie LaCroix | Marion Shattuck | Burlington |
| 1979 | Kwiniaska | Mary McNeill | Sheila Darrah (playoff) | Kwiniaska |
| 1980 | Ralph Myhre | Mary McNeill | Cindy Paquet | Kwiniaska |
| 1981 | Burlington | Sheila Darrah | Cindy Paquet | Stowe |
| 1982 | Manchester | Sheila Darrah | Cindy Paquet | Kwiniaska |
| 1983 | Barre | Mary McNeill | Cindy Paquet | Rocky Ridge |
| 1984 | Crown Point | Sheila Darrah | Marcy Fagan | Burlington |
| 1985 | Orleans | Cindy Paquet | Mary McNeill | Orleans |
| 1986 | Mt. Anthony | Cindy Mah-Lyford | Barb Munnett | Kwiniaska |
| 1987 | Burlington | Cindy Mah-Lyford | Linda Mandros | Burlington |
| 1988 | Sugarbush | Karen Wilder | Linda Mandros | Burlington |
| 1989 | Crown Point | Holly Reynolds | Barb Munnett | Rocky Ridge |
| 1990 | Orleans | Holly Reynolds | Barb Munnett | Orleans |
| 1991 | Barre | Holly Reynolds | Karen Ryan | Burlington |
| 1992 | Manchester | Holly Reynolds | Cindy Paquet | Burlington |
| 1993 | Burlington | Holly Reynolds | Mary Beth Birsky | Burlington |
| 1994 | Mt. Snow | Mary Beth Birsky | Susan Horton | Crown Point |
| 1995 | Ralph Myhre | Sue Horton | Kiersten Allbright | Crown Point |
| 1996 | Rutland | Mary Beth Birsky | Sue Horton | Crown Point |
| 1997 | St. Johnsbury | Sue Horton | Amy Reynolds | Rocky Ridge |
| 1998 | Tater Hill | Sue Horton | Libby Smith | Basin Harbor |
| 1999 | Neshobe | Libby Smith | Kiersten Allbright | Rutland |
| 2000 | Newport | Libby Smith | Margie Mather | Rocky Ridge |
| 2001 | Manchester | Libby Smith | Margie Mather-Bowes | Rutland |
| 2002 | Champlain | Libby Smith | Andrea Brown | Williston |
| 2003 | Brattleboro | Libby Smith | Andrea Brown | Rutland |
| 2004 | Barre | Andrea Brown | Kristin Turcotte-Mahoney | Rutland |
| 2005 | Crown Point | Reggie Parker | Molly Aronsson | Burlington |
| 2006 | Ralph Myhre | Molly Aronsson (Playoff) | Tiffany Maurycy | Williston |
| 2007 | Enosburg Falls | Molly Aronsson | Reggie Parker | Rutland |
| 2008 | Haystack | Teo Poplawski | Molly Aronsson | Rutland |
| 2009 | Burlington | Molly Aronsson | Catherine Shomo | Rutland |
| 2010 | Neshobe | Holly Reynolds | Catherine Shomo | Rutland |
| 2011 | Rutland | Kimberly Wong | Lindsay Cone | Rutland |
| 2012 | St. Johnsbury | Holly Reynolds | Reggie Parker (playoff) | Rutland |
| 2013 | Manchester | Madison Corley | Kristin Mahoney | Rutland |
| 2014 | Orleans | Madison Corley | Chloe Levins | Williston |
| 2015 | Brattleboro | Madison Corley | Tiffany Maurycy | Williston |
| 2016 | Green Mountain | Holly Reynolds | Tiffany Maurycy | Burlington |
| 2017 | Barre | Holly Reynolds | Jeanne Morrissey | Williston |
| 2018 | CC of Vermont | Tiffany Maurycy | Miranda Milne | Burlington |